Mark Schenker on addiction, Part 1: What is addiction

Mark Schenker defines addiction and talks about his integrative model in this 3-part series.

Part 1 – Part 2 – Part 3


Read transcript

Serge
Hi, Mark.

Mark
Hey, Serge, how are you?

Serge
Good, thanks.

Mark
Okay.

Serge
So you’re a psychologist who has been specializing in addictions. How did you get into that?

Mark
Well, contrary to a lot of stereotypes, I got into it just by happenstance. I needed a job. I got a job at a drug clinic in Chester, PA, just before the crack epidemic hit.

And I didn’t know what I was doing. I was trying to apply family therapy to addiction, which had modest success at best. And over time, I became more interested in the area, which as luck would have it, since I was in it.

And then I began getting interested in AA. One day I was working at an outpatient program and somebody didn’t show up. So I went upstairs to go to the AA meeting that I knew had been up there.

And it was, it opened my eyes. It was a revelation. I’d always thought it was kind of a cult and it was kind of, you know, had wacky language and was, you know, spirituality involved and all this kind of thing.

But it was really impressive to hear how the people spoke with each other and how real they were with each other. And the fringe benefit was the next day I went to work in the inpatient unit and everybody, all the patients thought I was the cool guy. I was the only doctoral level staff member who had ever showed up.

And that cachet stayed with me for months and months and months, even after the patients had left. I was seen at the Kool Gung. So my earlier orientation had been family therapy.

I was raised on psychodynamic theory and humanistic theory. I went to Brandeis, so Abe Maslow was walking around campus, and Maury Schwartz was a mentor of mine. Then I encountered systems theory, but I have to say that my approach to addictions, to a lot of other kinds of treatment has really been influenced by AA.

A lot of their worldview has seeped into my treatment in addictions and in other problems. And it’s become a really valuable resource for me. Having said that, I’ve also moved beyond that.

Somewhere around 2000, I read Recovery Options by Joe Volpe Kelly, who I was able to work with after that. And it was a guide to all the various methods of recovery that AA was not the only one. Years later, I read Slaying the Dragon by William White, which is just an incredible book.

And it’s the history of recovery movements from the Revolutionary War to now. and it places all the recovery programs of which there have been many in a historical context and makes it very valuable very um it gives a real history and a place for both aa and all the other things that are uh that have come along uh again one other thing about aa is that when it came along in the late 30s, it was the only game in town. Psychology and psychiatry had neglected addiction.

I think Bill Miller said that at that point, if you were an academic looking at addiction, you were going to be confined to Siberia. That’s changed quite a bit. But AA influenced the way we look at addiction in a good way and in a bad way.

It’s also limited our view because in the AA worldview, there is addiction and there’s everything else. Whereas I think now we’re looking at it more as a continuum. And I’ll talk about that more as we go along.

And one of the things for me is that psychologists and addictions counselors don’t always see things eye to eye. Two very different worldviews. And I’ve come around to seeing more of the addiction counselor’s point of view of it.

I never lose my psychological perspective on it, but I see that some of the psychological theories of addiction just don’t hold water. And it’s more fun to talk about resolving trauma and dealing with, you know, ego defenses. But ultimately, I look at addiction as a unitary primary disorder, which is somewhat independent of psychological factors.

They figure in, but the core of it, I think, is more physiological and genetic.

Serge
You’re a bit cynical about the psychological theories of addiction. And you think of it as something that is a phenomenon of its own.

Mark
Absolutely. I think it’s a mistake to look at addiction as a symptom of an underlying disorder. I’ve seen too many people who are being treated by psychologists, psychiatrists in good, with good intentions.

Well-trained people, but they’re taking the premise, which is fairly logical. that, well, a guy’s using cocaine because he’s unhappy, he’s depressed. So if we treat the depression, the cocaine use, drinking, whatever, will go away.

And it just doesn’t seem to work that way.

Serge
So maybe that’s a good place to talk a little bit about your definitions of addiction.

Mark
Sure. And again, when we talk about addiction, We’re not talking about substance use. Most people in our culture, in our society, will be able to use certainly alcohol, very much marijuana, but even cocaine and heroin.

It’s possible to use those in a moderate fashion. In terms of opiates, we know lots of people who are prescribed Percocet, let’s say, or Vicodan, take two pills every six hours. You come back five years later and they’re taking two pills every six hours.

They don’t become addicted to it. And we’ll define addiction in a minute. There is a normal place for the substance.

You don’t want to go get your wisdom teeth taken out without Vicodan or Percocet. you don’t want to do all sorts of other things without these various chemicals. The problem comes when people develop an addiction.

And when I say addiction, let me say one or two preliminary things. In DSM-2, which I have on the shelf, and I won’t pull it down, addiction was defined as a personality disorder. It was seen as a psychological phenomenon.

When DSM-III came along, they made an important distinction between dependence and abuse. Abuse meaning you had some problems that came about because of your substance use. Dependence was you have problems, but you also seem to have physiological components to it.

I thought that was a very useful distinction. But DSM-5 has taken it further and has construed it as a continuum that there are mild problems, moderate problems, severe problems. Now, in some ways, especially if you look at the codes, mild problems has the same code as abuse, and these other two have dependence.

So we’re, you know, diagnostically, it ends up being a very similar animal. But to look at it as a continuum is a whole different matter. And what we see now, or what I see anyway, is that different treatment applies to people at this end of the spectrum and that end of the spectrum.

In the milder levels of disorder, psychological factors figure more prominently. As you move towards the more serious end of the spectrum, psychological factors are there, but they’re secondary. Well, I’ll get into moderation versus abstinence.

The other important thing to understand in terms of the definitions of addiction is to see addiction as a primary disorder. It has a life of its own, independent of any psychological origin. So there’s an important point to distinguish between the initiation of substance use and its development into addiction, into a substance use disorder.

There are healthy social uses of alcohol. People will say, oh, he’s using for the wrong reasons. He went to a party and he has to smoke marijuana to deal with his social anxiety.

Well, that’s why we have alcohol. That’s why we have marijuana is to facilitate some of those social interactions. The problem comes when the person loses control over it.

And then it becomes a different primary entity. So just to create a visual here, because I don’t have my blackboard here, A traditional view of it is the person has a conflict, a disorder, a stressor. That leads them to drinking.

I’m not saying drinking, but really 99% of this applies to drugs too. This leads to this. So that leads to the typical functional thinking that, well, if we address this, this will not be an issue.

the problem is that this now has a life of its own that’s the primary issue that’s the primary issue and that in these situations that needs to be addressed before this in fact in a lot of cases when this is resolved this dissipates that the underlying the so to speak underlying problem turns out to be an artifact of the addiction.

Serge
Yeah, yeah. So you’re really talking about reversing the issue on its head.

Mark
Yes.

Serge
Clearly that when you’re talking about something that’s beyond mild, the issue itself is the addiction. And the factor that might have caused it is less important than resolves itself.

Mark
The not very delicate way they refer to this in a day is when you have diarrhea, you don’t sit around wondering what caused it. You go and take care of it. And it’s very, very much the same thinking.

You have to address the drinking first before you address anything that might have triggered it. And in this view, too, by the way, this is not seen as a cause of this. This is seen as a trigger.

Serge
Yeah.

Mark
seen as something that may instigate it. There’s no question that some people drink, use drugs to hide from their problems as an escape. That’s not the issue, because that’s not altogether abnormal.

If someone has a terrible day at work and comes home and has a drink or two, that’s, as I said before, that’s why we have alcohol. That’s okay. If they have 10 drinks, then we have a different issue.

If they have a drink on the Friday when they get laid off and they keep drinking Saturday, Sunday, Monday, and Tuesday, we’re dealing with a different animal than the person who has a few drinks to ease their pain. I remember years ago reading something from Carl Menninger talking about healthy coping mechanisms, and he included moderate use of alcohol. So we have that, you know, as a reference point.

But getting back to the definition of addiction, I use an integrative model, and I think of it as concentric circles. The core of the addiction is in physiological issues. And those are basically three primary factors.

The first one is physical dependence, as evidenced by withdrawal symptoms when you take the drug away. And to bring that home, I often describe to people, if you don’t get your coffee in the morning, what happens? You get headaches, you get cranky, you get irritable.

You’re in withdrawal. You’re in caffeine withdrawal. Imagine that multiplied by 50 to 100 times.

That’s physical dependence. The second key factor is an elevated tolerance. The person who drinks can drink anyone under the table.

The person, I should say, who drinks. The person who has a drinking problem. the tolerance is elevated.

The tolerance may start out low and elevate quickly, or there are some people who the first time they drink, they drank a case of beer. And there’s some evidence that this is an inborn vulnerability, but we’ll get to that in a minute. The third factor, biological factor, is loss of control.

And this is the one that really comes closest to defining addiction. This is the phenomenon of one drink is too many, then a thousand won’t be enough. I often describe it to people as your off switch isn’t working right.

David Letterman says there’s no offsetting on the genius switch. For some people, there’s no offsetting on the drinking switch. Once they start, they can’t stop.

And on the basis of operant conditioning, they can’t say no when they see it. It becomes a phenomenon in and of itself.

Serge
Yeah, so that switch off is where that impossibility of using the switch is a key factor.

Mark
And I would take it a step further and say, I often refer to it as the switch is impaired. It may not be completely broken. There are people who might, in some circumstances, they will moderate their drinking.

But in other circumstances, they lose control of it. I worked with a young guy who had been kicked out of two colleges, had been kicked out as a summer camp counselor on the basis of drinking. But if he went out to dinner with his family, he would have a glass of wine.

If he was playing poker with his friends, he’d have a beer or two. Put him at a party, put him in a social event, put him at a place where, you know, loud music and girls, basically, and all hell would break loose. His ability to drink was impaired.

His ability, I should say, to control his intake was impaired. It wasn’t 100% broken. But the metaphor I use with people in that situation is, listen, if the brakes on your car failed one time out of five, you drive the car.

What’s your tolerance for risk? Are you willing to play Russian roulette? Now, the other thing about these two important things, you don’t need all three to have a problem.

The two classic subdivisions are the maintenance drinker who has physical dependence and a high tolerance, but never loses control. That’s the guy who kids around and says, I’m a functional alcoholic. I go to work every day.

I’m never drunk. Well, true. Come back to the one he’s 60 and his liver enzymes are going up.

Maybe that was something else. and this can morph into a larger phenomenon the other subtype is the person who does not have physical dependence but does have loss of control and may or may not have a high tolerance usually does that’s a person who can say honestly I’m not dependent on alcohol I don’t drink for weeks at a time but when he does drink all hell breaks loose again a colleague of mine who was in recovery said you know every time i drank i broke out in handcuffs i thought that describes it you know the um the other thing to know about these three factors is they are really physiologically rooted more than psychologically rooted uh there’s plenty of genetic studies that show that the heritability of addiction ranges anywhere from 50 to 60 percent that’s pretty high twins identical twins have three times a higher concordance rate than monos fraternal twins and much higher than siblings and there’s an incredible set of studies by a guy named Mark Shuckett out in California in which they gave college students measured doses of vodka and recorded their reactions. Kids whose fathers were alcoholic showed a much lesser response to alcohol than kids who were not related to an alcoholic, meaning that they were predisposed to have high tolerance.

that seems to be an inborn risk factor and take it a step further when they looked at those kids subsequently those were the kids who developed alcoholism were the ones with the high tolerance now just to finish out the model that’s the biological piece the next level is psychological factors which primarily include denial and defense mechanisms uh pure denial you don’t see that often But defense mechanisms, that’s our lifeblood. You know, that’s what we spend most of our time in treatment working with. Sense of identity is critical for people with addiction.

Over time, they start to think that that’s who they are. That becomes their frame of reference to look at the world. It’s a sign of adulthood being able to drink.

You know, drink and drive are the two things that kids look forward to. and emotional regulation is another psychological factor that has to be reckoned with ed cance and has a whole theory of of addiction as self-medication and there’s certainly a lot of validity to that but i don’t think that’s the whole story then the next level is social you know biopsychosocial like like we all have often have the social level relates to both peers and one’s definition of their self in society which goes back to identity peer influence can be benign or malicious most people when you come out of rehab let’s say most people will say hey good for you. I’m glad you did it.

There’s a small percentage of people who are looking to see you fall on your face. I don’t hear that very often. What I do hear is people who say, great, you’ve been to rehab.

Let’s go get a glass of wine. And you say, what are you talking about? Let’s just have one.

I’ve literally heard this exchange. They just don’t get it. But it’s not just that the people are going to induce you to drink.

It’s that being around them serves as a stimulus, as a trigger. And that’s part of the social. The enveloping level is the existential or spiritual level, It relates to people coming to accept that they cannot safely drink or use drugs, accepting that they have a basic flaw.

I heard this term earlier today, that they are broken. And that being broken becomes a spiritual stance. It becomes a recognition of your limited nature.

Bill Wilson in the big book of AA says, first of all, we have to quit playing God. Basically, we have to recognize that we’re human. As humans, we are vulnerable, we’re broken.

But in a deeper sense, that’s what binds people together. Ernest Kurtz wrote a terrific book about the history of AA and a great article about how AA works. And he talked about going to an AA meeting as a place where you can openly express your vulnerability and be accepted and it being mutually shared.

I don’t have any verbiage right, but that’s the gist of it. And finally, these four levels interact because society often defines addiction as personal failure, personal weakness. That leads to the shame at the psychological level, which means that a person doesn’t go get help.

It’s too embarrassing. It’s too humiliating. And so forth.

Serge
And finally,

Mark
the concept is that addiction is not located in the substance. It’s located in the person. The first step of AA says we’re powerless over alcohol.

The first step of narcotics anonymous says we’re powerless over our addiction, which in a way is more accurate. It locates the addiction in the vulnerability of the person. So that’s a quick version of the nature of addiction.

And of course, it’s more people on this end of the continuum. there are people on this end who like the good like the kid who had to not drink at parties but he could drink at social occasions you know small occasions there’s moderation you know and in fact there are more people who fit in this end of the spectrum than this end but these are the ones who really get attention these these number of people do most of the drinking and most of the damage from alcohol and drugs, you know.

Serge
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So you really very clearly see different components, and that’s why it’s an integrative model, because all of these things interact with each other.

Mark
Absolutely. And another way of construing it is that the outer layers all serve to reinforce that center core of biological maladaptism.

Serge
Yeah, so maybe that’s something that is to really use a visual metaphor of concentric circles that you mentioned at the beginning and remind people of this. At the center, is that biological predisposition? Then you have the psychological circle, then a wider circle that’s a social circle. Then you have the existential question. And then related to the biological, the genetic factor and the interaction between levels.

Mark
You’re really getting it. I feel like I’m actually getting my points across. Yeah.

Serge
Yeah.

Mark
And by the way, those circles, I have not, no one else that I know of has done this, but I think those are very useful for treatment planning. Where does this person need the most work? We usually, as psychologists and treatment professionals, we usually address the psychological level.

But you have to address the social level. We often do that in terms of family therapy. You know, the tendency of families to scapegoat the person, to enable the person, the opposite level of it.

You know, it’s a growing topic, but the role of spirituality in psychotherapy.

Serge
Yeah.

Mark
I think, anyway, you could use those levels to say, where do we need to pay our attention?

Serge
mm-hmm so then from there maybe we could go to the concept of disease for addiction

Mark
sure sure and sure um and very simply i think at this end of the spectrum we’re talking about a disease at this end of the spectrum i’m not so sure you know whether that applies some of the people, by the way, at this end of the spectrum in the early stages of getting there, but a lot of them are not. It’s interesting. There was a book, I think 1960 by Jelanet called The Disease Concept of Alcoholism.

And Bill White says that it’s the most quoted and least read book in the entire field. And I’m proud to say that I’ve actually read it. It took me years to get up the to open it.

And what Jelinek says is not that it’s a disease, which people who haven’t read it say, well, Jelinek says it’s a disease. Jelinek breaks it down into a number of subtypes, some of which he says are disease entities, the others are not. So it’s a little more subtle argument than addiction is a disease.

I think that the argument for it being a disease are A, the biological, physiological elements we talked about, and the chronicity of it. Again, for people at this end, this is a chronic condition. This end, maybe not.

The nature of it being a chronic condition means that it’s up to the person who has the problem to treat it. You have pneumonia. You go to the doctor.

He prescribes you penicillin or whatever they use nowadays. I’m an old guy. You break your foot.

They put it in a cast. They fix it for you. You have diabetes.

Well, they prescribe medications, but it’s on you. You’re going to have this for a long time. There are things you need to do to stay healthy.

Addiction is much the same kind of entity. If you have it, it’s on you to keep it under control. What’s so interesting about this is Tom McClellan, who’s a very important researcher, did a study in 2000, comparing several different types of chronic illnesses, addiction, hypertension, diabetes, asthma.

And he looked at relapse rates. And it’s something I often use with patients. Which one had the worst relapse rate?

They always say, oh, addiction. No, they all had about the same. It’s all contingent on following a program, following basic guidelines of that disease.

If you have kidney problems and you don’t go for your dialysis, you will die. That’s on you. And some people say, you know what?

I don’t want to do this. They don’t go and they die. They choose not to follow through on the treatment.

With addiction, I often describe it as getting support, avoiding high-risk situations, and learning to manage your internal emotional states. They often call that halt. Hungry, angry, lonely, tired.

Remember it. And then most people would add boredom and jealousy. Those are the two that come up most frequently.

And just to finally, to sort of integrate this, I often draw a yin-yang and say one half of this is your disease that you are not to blame for. You were born predisposed. Most people.

There’s always somebody who strikes out of the blue. You were born with this. You did not ask for it.

You didn’t cause it. You didn’t intend for it to happen. You did not create this.

but the other side of it is you have responsibility to do something about it both sides have to be considered the um the notion that you’re not that you’re not guilty of having this is important in relieving the shame that people come in with and we could talk about that more in treatment but i emphasize the difference between you know having having a disorder that you didn’t ask for, but you still need to take responsibility for it. That’s kind of a big chunk of what we do in treatment. And I think that’s a reasonable point.

Oh, I know the one other thing, the critique of the disease concept, one of the most serious critiques of it is, oh, it’s just a cop-out. People are using that as a way of evading responsibility. And if you go to any kind of AA meeting, you’re going to see that that’s not at all how it works.

The way it works is you’ve got this disorder. What are you going to do about it? I’m sure it’s not a true story, but the story is a guy who’s alcoholic gets stopped for a speeding ticket, and he says to the cop, oh, I’m an alcoholic. I’m rushing off to my AA meeting. If I don’t make it, I’m likely to drink, and the cop pushes me and he says he has it back to him and says why don’t you reread big four uh why don’t you reread chapter four of the big book you know oh this isn’t going to work on this guy this guy’s in recovery too so i think that that that nature of uh that argument that it’s a cop out just doesn’t match reality and that’s which is not to say there aren’t some people who say oh for me you know i have i can’t go to the party well you know there are a lot of

Serge
alternatives to that yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah so that’s that gives a context that putting it in the context of other chronic diseases and that dance between what you are given by nature and what you do to deal with it?

Mark
It’s a metaphor that really reverberates with a lot of patients who, as I said, come in thinking I’m a horrible human being. No, you happen to have a disorder. I used to work at the Karen Foundation. They had a sign above the door that said, you’re not a bad person trying to get good. You’re a sick person trying to get healthy.

Serge
So that sounds like it could be a good way to conclude, but just maybe let’s check if there’s something else you might want to add.

Mark
No, I have a million stories I could tell, but then we’d be here all night. No, I think that the, obviously this is a telegraphed version of what I can spend hours and hours elaborating on. But, no, I think this lays the groundwork for talking about, you know, how do you go about treating it? How do you go about addressing it? Especially if it’s primarily a a disease entity.

Serge
Yeah. Thanks, Mark.

Mark
Thank you.

Copyright ProactiveMindfulness.com


Mark Schenker is a licensed psychologist with 40 years of experience working with patients with substance use disorders. Dr. Schenker has written “A Clinician’s Guide to Twelve-Step Recovery” (Norton, 2009) and the chapter “Addiction Treatment Settings” for the APA Handbook of Clinical Psychology (APA, 2016). He has taught and supervised clinicians at universities and treatment programs, and has presented nationally and internationally (well, Toronto). He received the 2017 “Addiction Professional of the Year” award from the Caron Foundation, and a Presidential Citation from APA Division 50 in 2018, where he has served on the Board of Directors. He hosted a monthly Clinical Conference Call on behalf of Division 50, featuring speakers and callers from around the world. He is committed to training clinicians to address the problem of addiction in their practices. Dr. Schenker maintains a practice outside of Philadelphia with a focus on addiction psychology and family/couples therapy.




Continue exploring

Continue exploring Proactive Mindfulness with our newsletter


Current events

embodied presence Embodied Presence: Building preparedness to meet life's pressures
focusing-oriented therapy The mindful & proactive edge of Focusing-oriented therapy