Stephen Batchelor and Serge Prengel talk about finding meaning through experiences and encounters rather than just ideas. Stephen Batchelor shares the journeys that have shaped his understanding of Buddhism and mindful living. We explore the importance of questioning established doctrines and embracing diverse spiritual or philosophical traditions to foster continuous inquiry and growth.
Stephen Batchelor is a writer, translator, teacher and artist. Born in 1953, he was ordained as a Buddhist monk at the age of twenty and spent ten years training in the Tibetan Geluk and Korean Sŏn orders. In 2015 he co-founded Bodhi College, a European educational project dedicated to the understanding and application of early Buddhism. He is the author of the bestselling Buddhism without Beliefs (Riverhead). His most recent publication is Buddha, Socrates and Us: Ethical Living in Uncertain Times (Yale University Press). He lives in south-west France with his wife Martine. See website.
Read episode transcript
Serge Prengel
Hi Stephen.
Stephen Batchelor
Hi, Serge. Nice to be here.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah, good to be with you. So we’re going to be talking about making sense of life, but not from just ideas, but how we get that sense through experiences and encounters.
Stephen Batchelor
Well, that’s what I, you know, that’s what this book I’ve just written called Buddha Socrates and Us is yet another attempt. I’ve written a number of books and I think all of them are trying in one way to do the same thing. They’re trying to share with a wider public what I found through my studies, my meditations, my…
readings, my practices, my encounters, my journeys and so forth and so on over the last 50 years. And I think this current book does in fact kind of encapsulate a lot of material that is brought together between two covers. And it jumps between the Greece and India and China and all sorts of places. But you’re right. It’s really about, you know, how does this process lead us to understanding?
Is it just about books? Is it just about ideas, philosophy? Or is it just as much about, and I think it is, it’s about the people we meet. It’s also very much about the stories we hear. It’s not just about providing, giving us information about Buddhism or Greek philosophy. It’s also learning about who the Buddha was and who Socrates was and who these other thinkers and other characters who appear in the pages of the books. You know, what were these people like? What sort of world did they live in? And what…
and what they did then in antiquity, how does that speak to us or does it speak to us?
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So we’re not going to be talking about this is Buddhism or this is about Greek philosophy or philosophy, or maybe not even about, well, this is Socrates or this is Gotama, as known as Buddha. But you’re talking about through the experiences of people from as much as we can figure out of how they made the decisions they made and the ideas they evolved in their time.
the poignancy about how it applies to us doing something like that in our time.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, that’s what I’d like to our conversation to expand.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah. And so part of it is your own journey and the arc of this journey from Englishman to student of Buddhism and to expanding your notion of what it means for you to be inspired by Buddhism.
Stephen Batchelor
Well, that’s right. I mean, I left England when I finished high school, grammar school as we called it in Britain, and pretty much immediately went off to India and encountered Tibetan Buddhists around the Dalai Lama in Dharamsala. And that’s really where my journey began. And that is now more than 50 years ago. So my whole adult life, I’m 72 now.
I was 19 when I arrived in India. And as soon as I encountered these Tibetans, I felt that this was a people, a culture that was not only deeply attractive, but it was embodied and incarnated in these incredible people that I met. And remember that the Tibetans at that time in 1972, they were only out of Tibet for 13 years then.
not long ago. And they were basically, I think, both traumatized, but also, you know, grateful to have found refuge in India. But these are people who had none of the privileges that I grew up with in England. And yet they radiated a quality of humanity, a well-being, a groundedness in their own bodies,
And this, I’m not just talking about the Dalai Lama and the senior monks, just the ordinary Tibetans I met on the streets, simple people. And it was to see Buddhism incarnated in their lives that made Buddhism a viable option. It wasn’t something I was learning just from books anymore, but it was something that was…
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
part of these people’s existence and something absolutely essential to their identity as Tibetans, as practitioners of this religion. And that’s what I learned from the interactions with the…
Serge Prengel
Yeah. And so what strikes me is that sense of what was very appealing to you was the quality of being, the quality of presence, the way of being human that you saw radiating from people. And so you didn’t go there with the idea, I’m interested in these ideas, but you know, I’m kind of curious about what it is that helps these people be the human beings they are.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
I think it’s probably a little bit more complicated than that. Another dimension of this whole journey is that it was basically an outcome of the romantic idealism that flourished in the 1960s in America and in Europe. And I went off to India with all kinds of starry-eyed notions about, you know, mystical east and all that stuff. And so I was looking for something, but what I was looking for was also filtered through
my imagination of how wonderful and enlightened and different these Asian people are, Tibetans, Indians, Japanese, whatever. And that I think was also a symptom of my alienation. Someone who had grown up in this culture, very privileged in many ways, but also constantly hitting a brick wall. There was something about this culture that didn’t really fit with me.
I felt, know, probably by the time I was 15 or 16 years old, I kind of felt something was missing. Partly what was missing was religion, I felt, because I hadn’t been brought up as a Christian. I’d been excluded from any kind of religious education by my family. And on the one hand, that gave me a freedom to not be indoctrinated by some Christian beliefs. But on the other hand, it also left a kind of a…
kind of a void, not a good Buddhist void, but rather a kind of an aching void, a sense that something was missing, that I hadn’t really engaged with life in a way that I could potentially do. And so the journey to the East, and this was again, not just me, it was a generational movement at that period.
was I think very much about a real quest to resolve something that was felt as a kind of disquiet, a kind of an anxiety perhaps, a sense of alienation is the word that comes to mind, of being cut off from life in some weird way. so yeah, I did arrive and I met the Tibetans, certainly, they certainly inspired me.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
But at the same time, I was still projecting a lot of rather fanciful ideas probably onto these people, especially onto the lamas. And I kind of fell into this world with my friends who were of a similar background and they’re in Dharamsala as well. And became totally enmeshed and drawn into their world and not very critically at all.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
And so my journey into Buddhism kind of had two phases, the kind of the naive, romantic idealism that motivated me. But once the effects of that began to wear off, and particularly since I realized that in the end, Tibetan people are just like us, know, they’ve got problems and they can get angry and they have their own…
know, quirks and habits, and they believe a lot of stuff that actually, rationally, I can’t really accept. And so you start finding yourself not in just a sort of a passive absorption of wisdom from the East, but you start hitting up against ideas that are not so easy to swallow. Like, for example, I remember studying about the 18 Buddhist hells, all of which are described in great detail.
presumably and also presented somewhere beneath the earth somewhere and I couldn’t really see the point of all that and It is I you know, I didn’t really want to get back into that kind of Well, so I began sort of teasing apart
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
Yes, yes.
I want to highlight something you were just saying about they’re like us, know, they’re people, they’re human beings like us. And so, you know, after the pull to the glory of the East, the wisdom of the East is realizing, well, you know, they can be as dogmatic and doctrinaire as our old religions are and
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
that their people, their human beings. And so then not just using Buddhism as an influence, but, know, for instance, in this book, counterbalancing it with the philosophy from Socrates and the West and discovering a lot of convergence.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, that is true. this was particularly the case with the school of Buddhism that I became part of in Dharamsala in India, the Gelug school, which is of the different schools of Tibetan Buddhism, the most scholarly in a way. And so the teachers I was attracted to weren’t those who were explaining how to…
recite mantras and visualize mandalas and all of these exotic aspects of Tibetan Buddhism. But I was more drawn to those teachers who were actually much more interested in the underlying philosophy and ethics and traditions of thought that are quite similar with what we find in, say, the Greeks and in aspects of contemporary philosophy as well.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
I kind of went that way into Buddhism and I was very much encouraged by my Tibetan teachers not to just take things at face value but to investigate whatever you study and you test it. Again, a word exactly you find in Socrates, this testing, this elactic approach. At the time I knew nothing about Socrates, we’re 50 years ago, but it was quite striking in
in exploring and discovering Socrates many, many, years later, that many of the same kind of emphases were found there in his approach to life as I encountered with my Buddhist teachers, both Tibetan teachers and then later my Zen teachers.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, which is which is a way of moving away from the notion that there is one particular school of thought that has all the answers, but actually discovering that within different schools of thought, you can have a convergence. within each school of thought, you can have some very dogmatic and some very wrongheaded stuff and something that’s more open. And so in some ways, what I’m hearing is
a veering away from just defining yourself as Buddhist, but kind of finding a larger brotherhood of human beings who have similar ideas or similar perspective.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
Yes, that sums it up actually quite well. Of course, when I knew nothing whatsoever about Buddhism, which was the case back in those days for most people, I had to spend a lot of time actually figuring out what Buddhism was trying to say. so, without doing all of that hard work, reading lots of texts, learning the Tibetan language, for example, in order to get back to the source materials, having endless discussions with the teachers and…
my fellow students and so forth and so on. In that way, I arrived at a reasonably comprehensive view of at least Tibetan Buddhism, but at the same time, I was being asked not to just take this for granted, but to actually check it out, really question whether this really does make sense or not. And that of course then became very much a philosophical inquiry.
And in that way, it began to open up other questions in myself, questions of meaning, questions of purpose, and so forth and so on. You know, how to live one’s life as fully and richly one can as a human being.
Serge Prengel
So maybe that’s where we talk a little bit about ethics because the word ethics can sometimes be used in a way that feels rigid and trapping people into a set of rules. And it’s clearly not the way you like it. So I’m just curious about the range of meanings that can be put into the word ethics.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
You
Stephen Batchelor
Well, ethics is one of these terms that is used in a very sort of vague way. mean, people will often confound it with morality, for example, ethics, morality. What’s the difference? I many people would be hard pressed to really tease those two apart. I’m using the word ethics in a quite specific sense, a sense that I think Socrates would have also had.
And I distinguish it very much from morality. think of morality, which is of course part of life as well. You can’t dispense with that. Morality is much more about learning what the basic social values and norms are of your society or your religion, and then seeking somehow to abide by those rules. And so in Buddhism you have the five lay precepts, you have…
200 and something rules for the Buddhist monks. And you have all other sorts of vows and prescriptions as well. So in that sense, there is morality, there’s lots of morality, but the whole conception of the Buddhist path is framed much more as a practice of ethics. Now by ethics, I’m going back to the word ethos in Greek.
which means character. And what really struck me in my engagement with Tibetan Buddhism and other forms of Buddhism too, was that what they were presenting was not an abstract doctrinal theory of reality or something like that, but it was about presenting you with a model of how you could live as a human being. It examined quite deeply questions of motivation.
you know, really moves you to lead a good life? It had a lot to do with a sense of your relationship with other people, with other forms of life. And so ethics is really about consciously deciding to lead a life that, consciously deciding to lead a life.
Stephen Batchelor
that optimizes your capacity to be the kind of person you most deeply aspire to be. In other words, to become what is sometimes rather flippantly called the best possible version of yourself. That’s ethics. Ethics, and ethics is not governed by rules. Ethics is more governed by your ongoing capacity to refine your responsiveness to
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
yourself, your own experiences to the, to other people, to other forms of life, to the environment and all of these things. And it’s a constant ongoing practice that you develop over time. Maybe through philosophy, it might involve meditation, it might involve, you know, thinking more carefully about some of the moral and ethical dilemmas of our time. But it’s all about shaping and forming the kind of person you are.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah. And so to pick up a few words from there to kind of them together, you’re talking about a model as opposed to rules. So that sense of it gives you a sense of how it is possible to engage with the world by seeing some people and some kind of idea of how to do it. And it’s about the engaging as opposed to following.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Serge Prengel
some rules. And so, and you relate it to that notion of practice. So in a way, it’s an ongoing practice of testing these rules and your way of engaging with the world and making choices and seeing what happens. So that brings us to a very different place from the notion of morality of moral rules. Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly. there’s my understanding, particularly of the early Buddhist tradition now, is that in a way, this practice, this evolution, this development of the virtues and so forth and so on, in combination with contemplative practice, leads you to a point, a rather important point.
in which you can actually let morality go. In other words, you can actually get to a degree of maturity, of understanding, that provides you with autonomy. And it’s at that point that the Buddha says the person enters the stream of the eightfold path, which is the Buddhist jargon for a way of life that encompasses the whole of your humanity. And such a person, as we find
described quite explicitly, is one who is no longer dependent on others. In order to lead an ethical life, you need to no longer be tied to simply following rules. But more than anything else, you need to have refined a capacity of judgment, ethical judgment.
Because I think one of the really challenging things we all face in life, and it’s not something that will probably go away very easily, is the fact that when we constantly find ourselves in situations where we don’t know what to do. And it could be a real dilemma for us, a life-changing moment in a marriage or a work situation. And constantly we’re getting into these situations where we come to a fork in the road.
And then we have to ask ourselves, well, how do I respond to this? What can I do? I can’t, sorry, yes.
Serge Prengel
So I wanted to, I want to maybe stay here a little bit because when you say not be dependent on others, I think you’re really, I want to point out it’s within the context of when you’re in a fork in the road, how do you make a decision? You’re not just following the rule. You’re not just kind of looking at your neighbor to copy what they wrote, but you’re trying. it’s in that sense of not be dependent on others.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Serge Prengel
And so I relate this to the difference between reactivity and responsiveness, that you developed enough breadth to figure out how to respond to the situation instead of just being determined by your reactivity.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly. No, I’m glad you brought that up. I mean, that is the crux really on which this whole process turns, as it were. The more you pay attention to yourself, the more that you notice how your mind behaves. And again, this is one of the great strengths of mindfulness and meditation. You get to see yourself a lot more clearly. what you see is not really always so wonderful. You see that you’re basically a creature of habit.
And you think that you’re kind of running the show and you’re a really interesting and important person, but you pay a little bit closer attention and you find that basically at a lot of the time, you’re just repeating the habits and the patterns and the norms of your society, your family or your religion or whatever. So you need to kind of see that going on. You need to see what I call reactivity. is not, you know, reactive habits that are probably the result of our evolutionary biology like
anger, greed, and so forth and so on, but also lots of reactive habits which are more in the domain of holding views and opinions about X, Y, and Z, that is largely unconsciously inherited and internalized from our upbringing, at school, church, wherever it is. And you realize more and more through this practice that you are not as free as you thought you were. You’re not as smart and clever and
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
cool as you thought you might have been. And that brings in a sense of humility, which is important, I think. And it’s that humility, I feel, that allows you perhaps to let go of some of your cherished opinions and ideas, to let go of things that you’ve held onto, emotions and people and so on, in a way that you have much lighter, more fluid relationship with life. And when you get to this point,
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
of really finding yourself on this path, you have the capacity more and more to make judgments and choices that are largely determined by your own capacity, your refined capacity, learned from previous experience, but also in judging and figuring out the particular nature of the situation you are dealing with.
Serge Prengel
Yeah. And so, and so we’re talking here about an understanding of mindfulness that is action oriented. It’s not an end in itself, but it is a way to gather the information, both in terms of what happens when I do this and what happens in terms of what happens inside, in terms of understanding our own limitations that leads to the possibility of transformation in a moment by moment way.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, no, that’s right. mean, mindfulness is arguably the, although mindfulness has become something very well known in the world today. When we were in India back in the seventies, we would never have ever thought that, you know, one day you’d be able to get mindfulness on the health service in Britain. It would have seemed like a crazy idea. But the reality is mindfulness has really taken off in a way. And the…
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
Danger is you think of mindfulness, well, that can’t really be what Buddhism is really all about. That’s just some useful little trick they figured out. But no, I don’t think so. think mindfulness lies at the very, very core of this practice. And it’s not a simple idea that you can just reduce to a clever definition. It has to do with the whole way in which your life becomes more conscious, you become more present.
Mindfulness also gives you a quality of stillness, a certain detachment, but most importantly, I feel, that you already alluded to, is that mindfulness is crucial if we’re going to be able to start responding to life situations, rather than simply going along with our accustomed behaviors and habits and so on that we’ve inherited from the past. And so that really, I think, was where Buddhism took me.
and not just from the Tibetans, but also I got involved with Vipassana meditation at that time as well. And I found what I was being taught was really providing me with an incredible set of tools, things I could use. And that’s been very, very important to me.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
And so when we were talking about this, and we’re talking about the ability, the tools to improve responsiveness, to improve the ability to be present in life and do things. and responsiveness is the opposite of reactivity when there is no self in a way, it’s like it’s automatic. So we’re talking to a certain sense of self and many people think of Buddhism as
a place of no self. And so maybe that’s a place to articulate a little bit of how this works.
Stephen Batchelor
Well, I’m glad you raised that, Serge, because this is really a massive misunderstanding. Recently, a scholar of early Buddhism went through all of the Buddhist canon, all the discourses of the Buddha, and didn’t find a single moment, a single time the Buddha denied the existence of the Self. And yet, in fact, the Buddha has, if you look at the Buddha’s very last,
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
some of the very last words of the Buddha were, you must become a refuge to yourself. Aptā, your self should be your refuge is what he said. He uses the word self in a totally non-problematic way. The idea that there is no self is a philosophical development, a metaphysical development on a body of, I think essentially ethical teachings that got…
slowly turned into a set of doctrines and dogmas and the notion of ultimate truth, for example, started to become very important and the division between conventional truth and ultimate truth. None of this you find in the Buddhist teaching. You find it in Buddhism, in all the Buddhist schools, but what’s really, to me, important is that by returning to the earliest sources, the equivalent basically of the Gospels in Buddhism.
is you don’t find any of that language at all. And I think Buddhism has thereby somehow come to seriously misrepresent what the Buddha was doing. I know that maybe seems objectionable to some listeners, but I think we’re at a point where we have to recognize that the forms of Buddhism that we find in the world today are the product of centuries of development in different Asian communities responding to those needs of
in those pre-modern times and for a range of reasons, what started as a very fluid, ethical, practical way of life became increasingly a set of religious doctrines, orthodoxies, and the attendant power structures that go with orthodoxies and doctrines. In other words, the building up of…
of authority figures, such as the senior monks and lamas and Zen masters and so on and so forth. It’s all understandable, it’s all terribly human and I imagine other religions, I’m sure you can see the same thing in Christianity. You start with Jesus and his fiturmen by the leg of Galilee and the next thing you know, you’ve got the Pope in Rome. why do human beings who start with these very…
Serge Prengel
Yes.
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm.
Serge Prengel
Right.
Stephen Batchelor
inspirational and I think very very vivid kinds of teaching and so on from Jesus or from the Buddha end up with these incredibly top heavy institutions where it’s all about power. And I feel we’ve got to a point with Buddhism today where we really do have to question all of that and then not just then dismiss Buddhism but really to go back
and try to sort of tease apart what are the core values and ideas and what has been added on, you know, not with any bad intention, but has just sort of accreted over the centuries. it’s an accumulation of fact, if you like, Go put it that way.
Serge Prengel
The accumulation of fact, yes.
Serge Prengel
Yeah. Yeah, yeah. And so, so that sense of, we started talking about it from the notion of self and thinking, well, okay, so this is something that is fact in a way, this is how a bunch of monks who have nothing else to do, argue about something and build added value by
Stephen Batchelor
you
Serge Prengel
building philosophical concept upon philosophical concepts. But in that sense, it’s veered away from the original intent, which was the aliveness of figuring out how to be yourself moment by moment.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly. That’s kind of how I understand it. And you see in Buddhism too, that this kind of evolution of the Dharma into some, Dharma is what the Buddhists call Buddhism, the teaching one might say, that the evolution of this and the institutionalization of it will often get to a point where the gap between the experts and the ordinary people becomes so large.
and so distant they are from each other, that it forces a kind of rupture, a breakdown, a revolt, or what in the West we would call a reformation. And so you find, for example, particularly in China, you see this with the emergence of Zen Buddhism. And Zen Buddhism was effectively a revolt against this top-heavy, dogmatic, priestly system of belief and so on.
a really direct attempt to get back to what the Buddha was doing as he sat beneath that tree. That’s what Zen practice is about. It’s about stripping away all of those beliefs and so forth in order to get back to the primary questions that life poses to us even before we have words to articulate what such a question is.
So what, in my understanding, is that religions of Buddhism is certainly no exception here, is that over time they accrete and develop these sort of doctrines and dogmas, and they become increasingly rigid and static, and the emphasis is constantly to preserve the Dharma, to preserve the teachings, and to keep the whole thing intact. And at that point I feel…
you won’t lose is something very essential, something very crucial to what it means to practice the Dharma, which is a willingness to keep the questions alive. Buddhism provides, each Buddhist tradition, let’s say, provides us with a particular set of answers to the basic human questions. And it considers the answers somehow much more important than the questions. And in fact, it forgets the questions.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
It doesn’t give, they’re just sort of, they’re not really articulated anymore, because we’ve got the answers. And then we have to go back to the questions. And that’s what Zen does. That’s what some movements in India, the Vajrayana movements also rejected the whole monastic orthodoxies and went back into ordinary life. We find it in Shinran in Japan, in the Pure Land School, same movement. And I think something similar.
is probably going to happen here as Buddhism engages with not the West, I think that’s an outdated idea, but with global modernity.
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm. And I think that the experience, say, as a person of being intimidated by the hierarchies and that sense of they have it so down pat that it becomes such a big block that who are you to have your own vision of it? And the thing that I find
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
Hmm.
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
very exciting, stimulating that brings a breath of fresh air makes me feel come alive, you know, in reading your things is that it gives the sense of coming back to the questions that you have, as opposed to how few of the prescribed answers you don’t have you have, you know, that the coming back to
the living, breathing, the difficulty of being a human being moment by moment.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm, exactly. Yeah, no, exactly. Yeah, that’s what it’s all about. And it’s much easier in a way to just accept what the religion presents as truth and to simply conform to that. And that gives all sorts of advantages. For a start, you begin to feel that you have a community, you belong somewhere.
And I think for many of us in the 60s and 70s, that’s what we didn’t feel again. And so the attraction of religion or any or a political party would be much the same. We don’t feel that we belong anywhere. We don’t really feel that we have a home on earth. And I think for many years, Buddhism gave me that sense. It gave me not only a coherent philosophy of life, but more importantly, it gave me a sense of being part of a community of other people who had similar.
values and ideas, both the traditional Buddhists in Asia as well as the communities in which I live which were mainly composed of Westerners.
Serge Prengel
Yeah. And so I think that articulating these ideas is a way of giving a home to people who, like me, don’t want to, you know, totally belong to one school by making it public that there are kindred spirits. And so it is possible for people
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly.
Serge Prengel
to feel that they are on a continuum of interest in this or that school, that they could be informed by Buddhism, more or less, but not necessarily fit as a card-carrying member of this or that club.
Stephen Batchelor
Hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
No, exactly. And I think you could even take that a little bit further. And, and again, this comes back to the theme of the book. It’s not just it’s not just that you, you know, are sort of a Buddhist without a club, but you also find it’s more and more interesting, actually, not to stay within the confines of, Buddhism, but to actually explore the spaces between different traditions. And so, you know, as someone
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
brought up in the United Kingdom. I will never grow out of the culture in which I emerged and I have to acknowledge that I’m informed by Christian values, I’m informed by Greek philosophical values, I’m informed by the scientific revolution and the vision of the world that has brought to us. These things are just as important and I think what I think people are finding more and more perhaps is
you don’t have to belong to a club. Or you could belong to a very, very select little club that is actually the club of people who don’t want to be in a club.
Serge Prengel
Yes.
Serge Prengel
Yes, but also that you belong to many clubs. You don’t have to just belong in one and that you can find some of the values you appreciate, say, in Buddhism in a Greek philosopher, but also in other people as well. And so it becomes something in which the pleasure is in recognizing those things that I value into a lot of different places instead of saying there’s only one place where it can be found.
Stephen Batchelor
Yes, that’s true.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly. Buddhism does in fact recognize that. mean, it has, for example, there’s a wonderful text called the Bodhicari Avatar, the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life that I translated many years ago by Shantideva. And he says that, his idea is that you can hear the teachings of the Buddha in the rustling of the leaves in trees.
In other words, the teachings are not just in the holy sacred Buddhist texts. They’re in nature. They’re in the world around us. They’re in the lives of ordinary people and they’re in Christianity. You’ll find insights everywhere in Islam, in Hinduism, in Socrates, in Plato. The wisdom is not the exclusive preserve of your particular tradition. That it’s spread throughout. And I think we are very fortunate in our
current day and age to have such easy access to such enormous literature, traditions, with the internet and so on, it’s even more available than it’s probably ever been in the past.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah. And so I’m tempted to hang on to this as possibly the way we end the conversation, especially in this day and age of a lot of difficult things happening in the world and a lot of divisiveness, maybe to point to the pleasure and that quality of finding the commonalities of things
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Serge Prengel
that bring us together, support us being who we are individually, but without, you know, a sense of cookie cutter. But you know that there can be commonality and diversity together.
Stephen Batchelor
Thank
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, I mean, I had a friend once many years ago who had this expression, celebration of difference. In other words, not to think of differences immediately, they’re against me, they’re different, they stand somewhere else. But actually to recognize that it’s through our differences that we’re able to then have the most fruitful engagements, the most fruitful understandings. And it’s through our differences
Serge Prengel
Yes.
Stephen Batchelor
that we’re really forced to extend our capacity to be loving and to be compassionate and kind, not to like the people who happen to be in our camp, but actually to go beyond that. And I think all the great religions seek this kind of universal understanding of their traditions. And Buddhism is no exception. I do consider myself a Buddhist, but I don’t belong to any particular Buddhist school.
If anything, I would label myself as a secular Buddhist. And again, there’s no real secular Buddhist school or organization or tradition existing yet. And I’m wary that at some point that might become another sort of fixed. It’ll be same problem. And there’s a story that Krishnamurti used to tell about God and the devil. And God and the devil are walking down the road.
Serge Prengel
And if it does, yes, yes.
Stephen Batchelor
And then God says to the devil, look, there’s the truth. I found the truth. And the devil says, well, give it to me and I’ll organize it for you. And that I think captures very well what we’ve been talking about in a way that there’s a human deep yearning for meaning and value and truth. But when you find it, you then immediately, not necessarily, but very often.
Serge Prengel
Yes. Yes.
Serge Prengel
You eventually kill it by…
Stephen Batchelor
then you kill it, you try to seal it off from other people, you guard it very preciously, you raise it up to impossible heights of excellence. And in so doing, you lose it.
Serge Prengel
Yeah. The beauty of the story, as you tell it, is it simple like a fable to say that this will happen. So in other words, don’t be surprised that it happens. Just the same way as you’re going to be distracted when you try to meditate, and simply it’s part of the story.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, I think that is the way to see it. We just have to recognize these are collective patterns of behavior that continuously repeat. And one of the great advantages that modernity gives in the understanding of Buddhism and these different traditions is that it affords us an historical perspective, which is quite alien in Buddhist traditions. They’re not terribly interested in…
in how Buddhism evolved and adapted in different cultures that’s never really spoken to them, but for us, and I think particularly where we grow up in a non-Buddhist world in Britain or America or France or wherever, and then we suddenly encounter Buddhism, and it’s not just one thing. you’re a Vietnamese person, for example, you would encounter Buddhism, but it would be Vietnamese Buddhism. You wouldn’t find anything else.
Serge Prengel
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
In modernity, in any big city, more or less anywhere in the world now, within a relatively short distance, I could probably find a Tibetan group, a Zen group, a Theravada group, a mindfulness group. They’re all present everywhere now. We live in such a different reality as Buddhists. We can’t ignore the fact that there is no such thing as Buddhism. There are many different.
buddhisms and all their lots of historical antipathies and disputes and debates and they all criticize each other. But the reality is that the diversity of the tradition to me is a symptom of its richness, its health, its vitality. And I think we need to celebrate those differences rather than try to figure out which one is got it closest to what the Buddha was saying. Not very helpful.
Serge Prengel
Yeah.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah, but also, like, as you said, all the traditions, not just of Buddhism, but all the other traditions. And so we live in a world that’s more complex, because we don’t have a simple organizing principle or a simple truth. But the also the richness of it is that complexity, and that allows us to navigate in between. And so just right now, I feel a sense of, you know, energy, sense of
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
and
Serge Prengel
you know, kind of pleasure at the idea of saying, you know, I want to revel in that diversity and possibly the possibility of finding connections in that diversity.
Stephen Batchelor
Hmm.
Stephen Batchelor
Absolutely, but I would add one proviso to that. I do think at the same time, we need to spend a lot of time, I think, educating ourselves, learning, having the humility to recognize that we don’t understand a great deal of things, trying to forge for oneself a set of values, a set of core ideas that actually are coherent. They all hang together to find, as it were,
Serge Prengel
Sure.
Stephen Batchelor
a pattern, a way of life that you feel deeply resonant with, you share with certain others, but you don’t then make the mistake of thinking that this is the truth. This is the way to do it. It’s a way that you’ve found to be of value and it may well change as your life goes on. But I do think you need some kind of groundedness in some kind of framework, no matter where you get it from.
Serge Prengel
Yeah, and so maybe I want to use for that the story you were telling about God and the devil. And so in some way, the opposite side of it is from the notion of being free comes the notion of glorifying ignorance. And so that would be the same sin, if you want, as being too rigid.
Stephen Batchelor
Thank you.
Stephen Batchelor
Mm-hmm.
Serge Prengel
just rejecting education, rejecting groundedness in education.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
No, exactly. mean, Buddhism is quite… One of the central ideas of Buddhism, I think, is very helpful here, and that’s the idea of the middle way. The very first thing the Buddha said, according to the text, I mean, who knows? But he said, the first words in the first sermon are, monks, I have found a middle way. And what is that middle way? That middle way is the noble eightfold path, blah, blah. So again, a middle way.
In other words, this, think, is really the kind of the field conductors, as you say in
Serge Prengel
Yeah, yeah, yeah. a middle way that’s not necessarily a fixed point somewhere in the middle, but can be like a shuttle that goes back and forth because it’s not static. Yeah.
Stephen Batchelor
not at all.
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah, exactly. The middle never stands still because life is constantly moving around it. And I think, again, Aristotle with his golden mean, the middle way is not an exclusively Buddhist idea either, which is actually a strength of this idea. It’s almost got a commonsensical element to it. You kind of feel intuitively that you want to somehow keep a life that’s balanced, respectful of
others’ views and opinions. And the middle way is just this constant balancing act. It’s like walking on a tightrope in a way. You’re constantly encountering new situations. You’re constantly being challenged not to somehow slip into an extreme position or reaction or whatever, but to constantly pursue this balancing act. so you need groundedness, but you also need freedom. Too much freedom, everything can fall apart.
Serge Prengel
Talk to you later.
Stephen Batchelor
too much groundedness and everything can get terribly rigid.
Serge Prengel
So I love that image of balancing that maybe could be maybe an image we leave with because it’s that moment in a balance implies stability, but it’s stability that’s in movement. And so that sense of being very alive as opposed to just dumped someplace, dead weight.
Stephen Batchelor
That’s right,
Stephen Batchelor
Yeah. Exactly.
Serge Prengel
and that sense of moment by moment engagement.
Stephen Batchelor
No, indeed. The middle way is constantly in motion. It’s like life is constantly in motion. It never stands still. And so to cleave to that middle point is perhaps one of the most difficult things to do, but I also think it is one of the most liberating things to do. And it’s also one of the most fulfilling things to do. And something I think that can help order not just our own inner life.
be more harmonious and balanced and so on. But our social life, our relationships, the communities we live in, to likewise seek in all of these situations to find the appropriate balance, the appropriate response to the world as we find it from moment to moment.
Serge Prengel
So this sounds like a great place to end this conversation.
Stephen Batchelor
I think it does, Serge. So thank you very much indeed. It’s been a lovely chance to get to talk to you again. And this is we’ve done this, isn’t it? So it’s good that this conversation continues. I’m glad. Thank you.
Serge Prengel
Yes, yes.
Serge Prengel
Thank you.
Copyright 2025 ProactiveMindfulness.com. All rights reserved.
Podcast: Download (38.1MB)